Thank you for visiting The Islander Newspaper Online.

We are currently updating our website to provide you better service and function.
If you would like to access the new site, please, click here: The Islander Newspaper

Sorry for any inconvenience. Our new site and service will resume shortly.

Web Master

The Award Winning & Best News on Anna Maria Island, FL Since 1992

"The Award Winning & Best News on Anna Maria Island, FL Since 1992"

Sunday, Apr, 20, 2014
Florida Press Assn. Award-Winning Web Site
Home Latest News Weather Sports Real Estate Classifieds Island Guide Islander Store

 SECTIONS

 • 

Main News

 • 

Classifieds

 • 

Opinions

 • 

Streetlife

 • 

Calendar

 • 

Fishing

 • 

Sports

 • 

Real Estate

 • 

Obituaries

 • 

Weather

 Features

 • 

Cortez Cook Off: The Results

 • 

Anna Maria Island Bridge FDOT replacement bridge

 • 

National Hurricane Center (Atlantic)

 • 

Advanced Search

 • 

I love AMI

 • 

Mystery Story

 • 

Fishing Laws

 Classifieds

 • 

Classifieds Page

 • 

Place An AD

 • 

Items for Sale

 • 

Garage Sale

 • 

Estate Sale

 • 

Announcments

 • 

Lost & Found

 • 

Pets

 • 

Transportation

 • 

Boats & Boating

 • 

Fishing

 • 

Kids 4 Hire

 • 

Help Wanted

 • 

Health Care

 • 

Services

 • 

Lawn & Garden

 • 

Landscaping

 • 

Home Improvement

 • 

Business Opportunities

 • 

Rentals

 • 

Real Estate

 Weather

 • 

Today's Forecast

 • 

10 Day Forecast

 • 

Today's Tides

 • 

Emergency e-mail

 • 

Storm Watch

 Archive

 • 

News Archive

 • 

2009 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2008 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2007 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2006 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2005 Top Notch Gallery

 • 

2004 Top Notch Gallery

 Useful Links

 • 

Island Links

 • 

i.wed

 • 

Islander Store

 • 

About this Site

 Contact Us

 • 

Islander Store

 • 

Subscribe

 • 

About Us

 • 

e-mail us

Story Tools

Date of Issue: March 17, 2005

Height ordinance could open up 'Bert Harris' can of worms

Anna Maria city commissioners set to hear the final reading of an ordinance at their Nov. 18 meeting limiting the height of new development along Pine Avenue in the residential-office-retail district might want to first consider the Bert Harris Jr. Private Property Rights Act enacted by the Florida Legislature in 1995.

The act provides for compensation to private property owners when an act of government is shown to lower the "future fair market value" of their property.

According to the Florida State Law Review (1996), the act, named after Highlands County legislator Bert J. Harris Jr., "protects a landowner's existing use of the land," or a "vested right to a specific use of the land from an inordinate burden" created by an action of a government entity.

While the BHA does say that an existing use of the land is "an actual or present use on real property," it adds that there are some circumstances in which a "prospective future use [of the property] may be considered an existing land use and therefore, compensable."

Does that mean lowering the building height along Pine Avenue from 37 feet to 27 feet takes away a future fair market value?

Sandra Oldham of 307 Pine Avenue doesn't know, but she wants the commission to consider the Bert Harris Act before taking any action.

In a Nov. 8 letter to the commission, Oldham said she objected to the ordinance because "it is unfair to property owners who choose to operate a business with a residence in the ROR district, and devalues the value of all properties in the ROR district." That's because the current ordinance allows a residence above the first floor of business up to the 37-foot limit, which would allow two floors of residential living area. A 27-foot height restriction would eliminate one floor of livable space.

Removing one floor of buildable living area could devalue the future fair market value of the property, she contended.

Under the BHA, landowners are entitled to seek compensation for the actual or future loss to the fair market value of a property affected by a government action, she said.

And an aggrieved property owner doesn't have to first file a civil action against the government entity, according to the FSU Law Review.

The Bert Harris Act says that the affected property owner can file a claim with the government body. The claim must include an appraisal that demonstrates the current or future loss in fair market value to the property by the government's action. The governmental body then has 180 days to respond, either to make an offer at resolution or to dispute the claim.

If the governmental body rejects the claim, the property owner can pursue the matter through civil court.

Under the BHA, compensation offered by the governmental entity does not necessarily have to be monetary, but could be in the form of other mitigation.

If the governmental body involved agrees to mitigation, but can't reach an agreement with the property owner, that owner can then proceed in civil court.

Oldham said she's making no claim that the height ordinance would result in any claims against the city under the BHA, only that it could be a "can of worms" if passed.

Bert Harris winners
A loss by any governmental entity under a Bert Harris claim could be expensive.

Since the Bert Harris Act was passed in 1995, there have been 200 claims, according to the FSU Law Review. Of those, 193 were either settled out of court or withdrawn by the applicant. Only seven cases reached a decision by a civil court, five of which were won by the applicant.

In the most recent Bert Harris case, residents of Vanderbilt Beach near Naples in Collier County won a $375 million civil court judgment in September 2004 from the county commission under the Bert Harris Act. The court ruled that a county commission ordinance had, indeed, taken away a future fair market value of the residents' property.

Have your say:

No comments for this page. Feel free to be the first

Username:

Contact:

(email or url)

Subject:

Your View:

Please enter the security code below:

security  

Get breaking news

Follow the Islander on TwitterBecome a fan of The Islander on Facebook

Sign up to receive breaking news alerts via e-mail. We'll send you a notice when the news and classifieds appear online every week, before the print edition hits the streets.

Click here for Gulf oil spill updates related to Anna Maria Island.

Historic Anna Maria City Pier Plank Walk

Put your name, your message, your memorial on the Historic Anna Maria City Pier prior to the Pier Centennial Celebration! And join the fun!

CLICK HERE for Stoltzfus e-mails and related court documents.


FREE Island
Vacation Guide:
get it here

Cortez Cookoff

Click here for 2010 Cortez Cookoff Winner and recipes

To advertise here, please
visit our rates page
or contact us at:
sales@islander.org
Phone: (941) 778-7978
Fax: (941) 778-9392

Back to top of Page

Home | Weather | Real Estate | Classifieds | Archives | Contact | Island Links
Islander Store | Subscribe About this site | Classifieds Page | Place an Ad
For Sale | Garage Sales | Announcements | Lost & Found | Pets | Transportation
Boats & Boating | Fishing | Kids for Hire | Help Wanted | Health Care | Services
Lawn & Garden | Landscaping | Home Improvement | Business Opportunities | Rentals | Real Estate

Our Privacy and Copyright Statements © 1992 - 2009, The Islander